What’s Missing from the Apple iPad?
*News Update January 28th, 2010
No Multi-tasking
Running iPhone OS 3.2 means that, at least for now, the iPad is shaping up to be a “one trick at a time” kind of pony. Of course, it’s entirely possible if not probable that Apple will correct this down the line in a forthcoming version of the iPhone OS — maybe even before the tablet ships — but as it currently stands the lack of multi-tasking could be a dealbreaker for some.
No Drag and Drop File Management
Another carryover from the iPhone ecosystem — and not a favorable one, in my humble opinion — is the requirement of syncing your iPad with another computer as the primary content management system for the device. Assuming it works the same way as your iPod or iPhone do now, you’ll only be able to associate your iPad with a single other device — and that’s a dealbreaker for a growing number of households that have media strewn across several computers, hard drives, network attached storage units and beyond.
You’ll be downloading content from the web and through the iTunes content store directly from the device, of course, but what about that set of files you just brought home from work or that collection of videos I want to dredge out from an old backup drive? In order to get them over to the iPad, I’d have to first dump them into iTunes, then perform a sync operation — instead of being able to simply drag and drop them over Wi-Fi or simply hook them in via USB Mass Storage (a great standard that’s been around forever!). There are third-party iPhone apps that allow file transfer via Wi-Fi, but how many steps are we needlessly adding to a process that was uncomplicated by USB Mass Storage years ago?
No USB Port
The iPad will sync itself via USB — but only when plugged in via its proprietary dock connector. That means there will be no direct attachment of all umpteen USB peripherals you already own. It even means you won’t be able to plug in an external USB keyboard you already own without buying a separate USB adapter.
No SD Slot
Speaking of storage: 16, 32, or 64GB is all you get — precisely because there’s neither a USB nor an SD card reader built directly into the iPad. That means you can’t stick a 16GB SD card in as a semi-permanent storage expansion option or pull files off an SD card without purchasing the aforementioned iPad Camera Connection Kit. Not only is that extra money out of your pocket, but it’s another proprietary dongle to cart around with you (and lose… repeatedly).
No Flash
The above shot taken from Apple’s presentation (hat tip: Engadget) demonstrates quite clearly another big omission from the iPad: support for Adobe Flash. It’s bad enough on the iPhone, but imagine loading up a nice video link on the iPad only to have it… simply not play.
We know Apple dislikes its lack of control over the whole Flash ecosystem, and that Flash is the leading cause of crashes on OS X. We can also prognosticate that Apple is hoping that HTML5 will take off quickly and start to disintermediate Flash as the primary technology powering video playback on the web.
Still, YouTube just announced their HTML5 player last week. It’s getting out there, but it’s the early days for widespread HTML5 support. It’s doubtful it will be in a position two short months from now to completely replace the Flash experience for web video, leaving a lot of ugly “plug-in missing” boxes to make an appearance on one’s expensive iPad tablet.
No HDMI Out
Speaking of video, there’s no handy, single-cable way to hook up an iPad to your TV set. Of course, this should have come as no surprise knowing Apple’s reluctance to support HDMI in any of its other products. Still, for a device that strongly hinted at being perfect for your living room, it would be nice to have the option to quickly hook it up for a big screen video experience.
Even to get video out at all, you’ll need a proprietary Dock to VGA adapter, which obviously limits you to VGA resolutions — there’s not even a DisplayPort out option, which Apple has been touting as a great alternative to HDMI. You’ll be able to pull up to 576p out with an (again, proprietary) Apple Composite A/V Cable — but this is composite video we’re talking here. Not HDMI, not component, not even S-video. The only upside to that is that, as the lowest common denominator just above a coaxial connection, your TV from the early ’90s will probably at least have this type of connector.
No 1080p Playback
And while we’re railing on the subject of video, it’s worth mentioning there will be no full HD playback (much less output) from the iPad. Given that 720p is pretty darn close enough (especially for a 9.7-inch screen), it’s more the annoying fact that if you have a growing library of 1080p video files you’ll most likely be unable to play them back without some sort of conversion step first (it’s possible certain formats and codecs could be natively downsampled, but it will remain to be seen how it will shake out in practical usage).
To be fair, it’s definitely a minor point considering the paucity of true 1080p content out there — but it definitely feels like an odd backwards step in a video trajectory that should be trending towards full HD, not away from it.
No Native Widescreen
Okay, just one more gripe about the display aspect of the iPad and then we’re done on this track, we promise.
The tablet’s resolution tops out at 1024 x 768, which falls into the 4:3 standard definition range and not the glorious, widescreen 16:9 high definition aspect ratio we’ve come to know and love. In fact, we’ve come to know and love it via Apple, who has been touting HD as the second coming for several years now. Remember when 2005 was “the Year of High Definition Video?” So then why, pray tell, is 2010 suddenly the Year of Composite Out?
No Camera
Really, no camera? Like, not even at all? Yep, there is no camera on the iPad. It was mystifying enough on the iPod touch, but to omit the camera here is a curious thing. That means no video iChat, no Skype video conferencing, no quickly snapping a pic of whatever and uploading it to Flickr/Facebook/Picasa/etc.
The iPad is clearly a device centered around media consumption, not creation.
No Full GPS
The Wi-Fi-only versions flat out have no GPS support whatsoever. The 3G versions have Assisted GPS, which makes use of the cellular connection to help pinpoint your location. The upside of Assisted GPS is it still tends to be fairly accurate — the downsides are there’s no absolute standard regarding what functions Assisted GPS will support to the end user, and you almost surely need an active cell connection to get your positioning information. That means if you stop paying for the mobile data service or are in a dead zone or other area of poor connectivity, your GPS is probably kaput as well.
No Open SDK
This one isn’t really a shocker either, considering Apple does it every time, but the brand spanking new Software Development Kit for iPhone OS 3.2 — which, despite the name, is the operating system the iPad runs on — requires developers to sign a Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) before getting access.
January 28th, 2010 at 11:31 pm
A friend of mine just emailed me one of your articles from a while back. I read that one a few more. Really enjoy your blog. Thanks
January 28th, 2010 at 11:33 pm
[...] Latest Mobiles Information » Blog Archive » What's Missing from … [...]
January 28th, 2010 at 11:55 pm
[...] Latest Mobiles Information » Blog Archive » What's Missing from … [...]
February 3rd, 2010 at 6:44 am
Order http://buy-cialis.icr38.net/Keftab – keftab online now – Patent Chance arava online easy – Unprecedented Price
February 6th, 2010 at 4:50 am
[...] Running iPhone OS 3.2 means that, at least for now, the iPad is shaping up to be a âone trick at a timeâ kind of pony. Of course, it’s entirely possible if not probable that Apple will correct this down the line in a forthcoming version …Next Page [...]
February 14th, 2010 at 11:33 pm
Greatings, Where are you from? Is it a secret?
Have a nice day
Truden
February 19th, 2010 at 1:11 am
I just got kaspersky internet security yesterday and I scaned my computer with a full scan and it found viruses… So I tried to quarantine them but every time i do that it asks me to open a file.. I’ve never seen that from any antivirus programs.. THere is also another option: ” clear all” which deletes report entry.. is that how you delete the infection or is there another way? santoramaa
March 5th, 2010 at 7:33 pm
Great Site. Was added to mybookmarks. Greetings From USA.